Using timers in a class

Hi all, I have the code below that is a simple 2 second timer that clears a flag to allow the program to exit the while loop and it works fine.

waitFlag = 1;
num = 0;
t = timer('TimerFcn', 'waitFlag=0;',... 
                 'StartDelay', 2, ...
                 'ExecutionMode', 'singleShot');
start(t); 

while (waitFlag) && (num == 0)
end

disp('Timer works');

Take that same concept and put it inside a class function and it doesn't work.

function ret = waitForSerial(obj)
            waitFlag = 1;
            t = timer('TimerFcn', 'waitFlag=0;',... 
                 'StartDelay', 2, 'ExecutionMode', 'singleShot');
            start(t);          
            
            % Wait for response to come in
            % waitFlag becomes 0 when timer expires
            % While is broken if timer expires or if serial data comes in
            while (waitFlag) && (obj.comPort.NumBytesAvailable == 0)
            end
            disp("Done waiting");
            if obj.comPort.NumBytesAvailable > 0
                stop(t);
                ret = obj.interpretMsg();
            else
                stop(t);
                commsErr(obj, "COMs timeout");
                ret = -2;
                return
            end
            delete(t);
end

What happens is I guess the timer doesn't start, it doesn't trigger or it doesn't clear the waitFlag because the program never exits the while loop. If there is some special behaviour regarding timers/callbacks within classes, any help would be greatly appreciated.

Answer 1

[Guillaume]

The problem is most likely one of scope.I'm actually surprised that you first version works, but I never use the char array version of the TimerFcn. The documentation doesn't specify in which context that char expression is evaluated (I'll be raising a bug report for that), but it looks like it's in the base workspace. So your original code would only work in a script. In a function or class method, which have their own workspace, the timer wouldn't affect the local variable.

The best way to fix your problem is, assuming a handle class to:

a) make waitFlag a property of the class

classdef yourclass
    properties (Access = private)
        waitFlag
    end
end

b) create a member function to handle the timer event

    methods
        function TimerCallback(this)
            this.waitFlag = true;
        end

c) use that callback as a timer function:

        function ret = waitForSerial(this) 
            this.waitFlag = false;
            t = timer('TimerFcn', @(~, ~) this.TimerCallback, ... 
                 'StartDelay', 2, 'ExecutionMode', 'singleShot');
            start(t);
            while (this.waitFlag) && (this.comPort.NumBytesAvailable == 0)
            end
            %...
        end

However, if the whole purpose of your timer is to wait a limited amount of time for some serial data, you may be better off with just attempting a read with a timeout. Overall it would be simpler and achieve the same result.