When to use Data Acquisition Toolbox vs. Simulink Real-time

6 views (last 30 days)
For what applications should I use data acquisition tools like Data Acquisition Toolbox vs. real-time testing tools like Simulink Real-time?

Accepted Answer

MathWorks Data Acquisition Toolbox Team
Data Acquisition Toolbox is typically used for the following applications:
  • Data Acquisition and Analysis: Data Acquisition Toolbox is designed for acquiring, logging, and analyzing data from a variety of sensors, instruments, and hardware devices. It provides a comprehensive set of functions and tools for configuring, controlling, and reading data from data acquisition hardware.
  • Offline Data Processing: If you need to perform post-acquisition data analysis, signal processing, or visualization, Data Acquisition Toolbox, Signal Processing Toolbox and MATLAB would be a recommended solution. Together, they offer a range of functions for data manipulation, filtering, spectral analysis, and more.
  • Custom Data Acquisition Applications: If you require flexibility in developing custom data acquisition applications using MATLAB, Data Acquisition Toolbox provides the necessary functions for building tailored solutions. You can even deploy a custom application using MATLAB Compiler.
Simulink Real-Time is typically used for these applications:
  • Real-Time Testing and Simulation: Simulink Real-Time is specifically designed for real-time testing, simulation, and rapid prototyping of control systems. It allows you to run Simulink models in real-time on dedicated hardware targets, providing accurate and time-critical simulations.
  • Hardware-in-the-Loop (HIL) Testing: Simulink Real-Time is commonly used for HIL testing, where the control system under development is tested against a physical plant or hardware components in real-time. It enables the integration of real-world hardware with Simulink models for thorough testing and validation.
  • Rapid Control Prototyping: If you need to quickly iterate and test control algorithms on real hardware, Simulink Real-Time offers a streamlined workflow for rapid control prototyping, reducing development time and enabling efficient algorithm refinement.
There are applications where both Data Acquisition Toolbox and Simulink Real-Time could be utilized, such as closed-loop control or audio processing. For these applications, algorithm update rate and timing requirements can help determine which tool is appropriate.
  • Simulink Real-Time can run real-time simulations of the control algorithm, while Data Acquisition Toolbox can acquire real-time feedback signals from sensors and provide control signals to actuators, enabling closed-loop control and system monitoring.
  • Use Simulink Real-Time for applications where the algorithm update rate is fast, has deterministic timing requirements, and requires a real-time operating system (RTOS)
  • Use DAQ Toolbox where the algorithm update rate is slow and has less stringent timing requirements.
  • If unsure about which tool to use, reach out to MathWorks for guidance.
Refer to this answer for guidance on key differences between the products.

More Answers (0)

Categories

Find more on Hardware-in-the-Loop Simulation with Simulink Real-Time in Help Center and File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!