Plot arrow as upper limits in errorbar when I don't have lower bound

21 views (last 30 days)
Hi,
I am dealing with a variable that is strictly positive, and for which the calculation sometimes give values of the errors that are larger than the value itself. For example "1+-3" cannot be reported like that but must be reported as "<4".
I also cannot plot them as regular errorbars. Sometimes in plots you see these type of data points as arrows pointing downwards, and I was asking if it is possible to do that in Matlab.
For example in the following code I want an arrow at point (56,11) pointing downwards. How do I do this?
y=[1 2 3 4];
x=[15 1 34 56]
ey=[0.1 0.2 0.3 7];
test1=find(ex>x);
y_upper=x(test1)+ex(test1);
x_upper=y(test1);
  2 Comments
Roberto Serafinelli
Roberto Serafinelli on 22 Nov 2022
Hi Kai, thanks for the answer. Take the fourth point, 4+-7. Since the variable is strictly positive, it cannot take the values from -3 to 0. Therefore 4+-7 means that y can be anything below 4+7=11. So I want Matlab to put a data point at y=11 and draw an arrow pointing downwards (only half error bar won't do, I need an arrow). If there is no way to do this I will use scatter with triangles but arrows are my first option, if it's doable in Matlab.

Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Roberto Serafinelli
Roberto Serafinelli on 23 Nov 2022
I solved this way, though it seems rather tortuous. I made a medley of both your advice, thank you very much for your help.
I hope is useful to other people googling the same thing:
x=[1 2 3 4 5 6]; % x variable
ex=[0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2]; %error on x
y=[2 3 4 7 6 12]; % variable that cannot be negative
ey=[1 1.6 2.4 9 4 14]; %error on y
% define some utility variables
x1=x;
ex1=ex;
y1=y;
ey1=ey;
i=find(ey>y); %search for all variables with upper limits
x1(i)=[]; %removes upper limits (this variable index 1 is for constrained values)
x2=x(i); %puts upper limits in this variable index 2
ex1(i)=[];
ex2=ex(i);
y1(i)=[];
y2=y(i);
ey1(i)=[];
ey2=ey(i);
y2max=y2+ey2; %This are the actual upper limits
kk=zeros(length(x2)); %as much zeroes as how many upper limits I have
figure('Position',[10 10 800 650])
hold on
e1=errorbar(x1,y1,ey1,ey1,ex1,ex1,'.','Color','black','MarkerSize',15); %plots constrained values with neg and pos errors
e2=errorbar(x2,y2max,kk,kk,ex2,ex2,'.','Color','black','MarkerSize',15); %plots upper limits as dots with x errors and no y errors
e3=errorbar(x2,y2,kk,ey2,kk,kk,'v','MarkerEdgeColor','black','MarkerFaceColor','black','Color','black','MarkerSize',6); %plots downwards triangles with only positive errors that connect to the dots of e2
set(gca,'Box','on')
axis([0 6.5 0 30])
set(gca,'Fontsize',18,'TickLabelInterpreter','latex')
xlabel(gca,'$x$','Fontsize',22,'interpreter','latex');
ylabel(gca,'$y$','Fontsize',22,'interpreter','latex');
hold off

More Answers (1)

Jeffrey Clark
Jeffrey Clark on 23 Nov 2022
@Roberto Serafinelli, using the e = errorbar call where the inputs are given to draw individual lines (see and Multiple lines with error barsl) will return a list e of the lines it creates for the data. The e can be indexed individually and modified as shown in ErrorBar Properties - for the individule error cases (e.g., negative values) you could use the Downward-pointing triangle marker arrow head and modify the error line lengths/colors as needed.

Tags

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!