Redirecting stdout via system(…,'-echo')

38 views (last 30 days)
Darren Engwirda
Darren Engwirda on 14 Dec 2016
Commented: David Wyatt on 25 Sep 2018
I often call computationally intensive command-line programs from within MATLAB using the system command:
[status, result] = system(cmd_line_for_my_low_level_exe, '-echo');
where the -echo option (supposedly) echoes console output (stdout) generated by low_level_exe in the MATLAB command window.
On Linux machines this works great, with MATLAB echoing the console output in (seemingly) real-time. Users get a nice continuous update on low_level_exe's progress.
On Windows machines this is not the case. It can often be many minutes in-between echoes, and users sometimes get impatient and assume the code has crashed...
Is there a way to increase/control the frequency of MATLAB's -echo, or possibly another, better alternative entirely? (I'd prefer to stay away from mex files to maintain compatibility with Octave).
Is this actually a MATLAB issue, or just a Linux/Windows incompatibility?

Answers (1)

Jose Lara
Jose Lara on 16 Dec 2016
Edited: Jose Lara on 16 Dec 2016
Darren, One thing to try to not use the second output argument, but write the output of the operating system command to a file. For example,
>> s = system(['echo ' cmd_line_for_my_low_level_exe ' >> out.txt']);
And read the file back into MATLAB:
>> r = textscan('out.txt');
It does add an extra line to your script but will be computed faster.
  1 Comment
David Wyatt
David Wyatt on 25 Sep 2018
I have the same problem as the OP.
However, I'm not clear on how to use textscan to show the output from the operating system command in "real time", since it is not (as far as I am aware) possible to easily loop while the system command is running, or to detect when the command has finished in another thread.
Please could you elaborate?
Many thanks in advance.

Sign in to comment.


Find more on Programming in Help Center and File Exchange


Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!