Why does this code run (20 to 100)% slower on R2025a compared to R2024b?

121 views (last 30 days)
clc
clear
close
syms t x1(t) y1(t) x2(t) y2(t) x3(t) y3(t)
G = 6.6743 * 10^-11;
%epsilon = 1e-4
m1 = 10^12;
m2 = 1*10^12;
m3 = 1*10^12;
r1 = [x1(t),y1(t)];
K1 = 1/2 * m1 * (diff(x1(t),t)^2 + diff(y1(t),t)^2);
r2 = [x2(t),y2(t)];
K2 = 1/2 * m2 * (diff(x2(t),t)^2 + diff(y2(t),t)^2);
r3 = [x3(t),y3(t)];
K3 = 1/2 * m3 * (diff(x3(t),t)^2 + diff(y3(t),t)^2);
L1x = diff(diff(K1,diff(x1(t),t)) , t);
L1y = diff(diff(K1,diff(y1(t),t)) , t);
L2x = diff(diff(K2,diff(x2(t),t)) , t);
L2y = diff(diff(K2,diff(y2(t),t)) , t);
L3x = diff(diff(K3,diff(x3(t),t)) , t);
L3y = diff(diff(K3,diff(y3(t),t)) , t);
r12 = r2 - r1;
r13 = r3 - r1;
r23 = r3 - r2;
dlugosc_r12 = sqrt(r12(1)^2 + r12(2)^2);
dlugosc_r13 = sqrt(r13(1)^2 + r13(2)^2);
dlugosc_r23 = sqrt(r23(1)^2 + r23(2)^2);
Q12 = G * m1 * m2 / dlugosc_r12^2 * (r2-r1)/dlugosc_r12;
Q13 = G * m1 * m3 / dlugosc_r13^2 * (r3-r1)/dlugosc_r13;
Q23 = G * m2 * m3 / dlugosc_r23^2 * (r3-r2)/dlugosc_r23;
Q21 = -Q12;
Q32 = -Q23;
Q31 = -Q13;
Q1 = Q12 + Q13;
Q2 = Q21 + Q23;
Q3 = Q31 + Q32;
eqn_1_x = L1x == Q1(1);
eqn_1_y = L1y == Q1(2);
eqn_2_x = L2x == Q2(1);
eqn_2_y = L2y == Q2(2);
eqn_3_x = L3x == Q3(1);
eqn_3_y = L3y == Q3(2);
syms X1 Y1 X2 Y2 X3 Y3
Q1_num = subs(Q1,[x1(t), y1(t), x2(t), y2(t), x3(t), y3(t)],[X1, Y1, X2, Y2, X3, Y3]);
Q2_num = subs(Q2,[x1(t), y1(t), x2(t), y2(t), x3(t), y3(t)],[X1, Y1, X2, Y2, X3, Y3]);
Q3_num = subs(Q3,[x1(t), y1(t), x2(t), y2(t), x3(t), y3(t)],[X1, Y1, X2, Y2, X3, Y3]);
syms vx1 vy1 vx2 vy2 vx3 vy3
state_dot = [
vx1;
vy1;
vx2;
vy2;
vx3;
vy3;
Q1_num(1)/m1;
Q1_num(2)/m1;
Q2_num(1)/m2;
Q2_num(2)/m2;
Q3_num(1)/m3;
Q3_num(2)/m3
];
f = matlabFunction(state_dot, 'Vars', {sym('t'), [X1; Y1; X2; Y2; X3; Y3; vx1; vy1; vx2; vy2; vx3; vy3]});
u0 = [-1e5; %x1
0; %y1
1e5; %x2
0; %y2
0; %x3
sqrt(3)*1e5; %y3
-11/2 * 1e-3; %vx1
11/2*sqrt(3)*1e-3; %vy1
-11/2 * 1e-3; %vx2
-11/2*sqrt(3)*1e-3; %vy2
11e-3; %vx3
0]; %vy3
tspan = [0, 1e9];
%options = odeset('RelTol', 1e-15, 'AbsTol', 1e-20);
[t_sol, u_sol] = ode45(f, tspan, u0);
t_anim = linspace(t_sol(1), t_sol(end), 5000);
u_anim = interp1(t_sol, u_sol, t_anim);
%%
% figure;
tor_1 = plot(u_anim(:,1), u_anim(:,2), 'r', 'LineWidth',1.5); hold on;
tor_2 = plot(u_anim(:,3), u_anim(:,4), 'g', 'LineWidth',1.5);
tor_3 = plot(u_anim(:,5), u_anim(:,6), 'b', 'LineWidth',1.5);
% xlabel('x [m]');
% ylabel('y [m]');
% legend('Ciało 1', 'Ciało 2', 'Ciało 3');
% title('Trajektorie ciał w układzie trzech ciał');
% axis equal
% grid on;
pozycja_1 = plot(u_anim(1,1),u_anim(1,2),'ro','markersize',10,'markerface','r'); hold on
pozycja_2 = plot(u_anim(1,3),u_anim(1,4),'go','markersize',10,'markerface','g');
pozycja_3 = plot(u_anim(1,5),u_anim(1,6),'bo','markersize',10,'markerface','b');
% xlim([-2e5,2e5])
% ylim([-2e5,2e5])
axis equal
for i = 1 : 1 : length(t_sol)
set(pozycja_1,'XData', u_anim(i,1),'YData', u_anim(i,2));
set(pozycja_2,'XData', u_anim(i,3),'YData', u_anim(i,4));
set(pozycja_3,'XData', u_anim(i,5),'YData', u_anim(i,6));
set(tor_1,'XData', u_anim(1:i,1),'YData', u_anim(1:i,2));
set(tor_2,'XData', u_anim(1:i,3),'YData', u_anim(1:i,4));
set(tor_3,'XData', u_anim(1:i,5),'YData', u_anim(1:i,6));
drawnow;
% pause(0.001);
end
This is an animated solution of the three body problem. On 2024b it runs perfectly fine. When we tried it on 2025a, the animation constantly hitches, the CPU usage is almost double and the runtime is much slower. The curves also look less detailed and jagged in some places. When we run in without drawing anything it seems comparable, but still slightly slower. All of this behavior persists across different hardware. Anybody else having this kind of problem with the new release?
  1 Comment
Princeton
Princeton on 29 May 2025
I am also having this problem. My n-body planetary simulation is also having constant hitches and slowdowns, with the planets being a bit shaky/vibrating throughout the program. As my animation goes longer and longer, the hitches only get worse and more frequent, to a point where it is unwatchable and barely progresses. This only happened in 2025a, and works completely fine in 2024b.

Sign in to comment.

Answers (1)

Adam Danz
Adam Danz on 15 May 2025
Hello @Mateusz, I ran your demo in R2024b and R2025a and can confirm a bit of a slowdown in 25a.
Please contact tech support and include your demo above along with your system information. Feel free to include the URL of this thread.
  1 Comment
Mateusz
Mateusz on 29 May 2025
Apparently, the new desktop is to blame, as support was able to reproduce my issue, not only on 2025a, but also on the demo desktop on 2024b. Unfortunately, I am disappointed to report that a MathWorks employee, having looked at the issue, responded with the link to an article about animation best practices...

Sign in to comment.

Categories

Find more on Symbolic Math Toolbox in Help Center and File Exchange

Products


Release

R2025a

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!