How to improve my inefficient code?

2 views (last 30 days)
Tomaszzz
Tomaszzz on 1 Mar 2022
Commented: Tomaszzz on 1 Mar 2022
Hi all,
I have a 21x288 table (attached).
I have a function that compares the variables and calculates the ICC (attached). For my purposes, I am running the following comparisons:
1 vs 2, 1 vs 3, 1 vs 4
5 vs 6, 5 vs 7, 5 vs 8
9 vs 10, 9 vs 11, 9 vs 12
and so on until the end of the table (numbers refers to columns)
I am planning to do so as below. Can this be done in a more efficient way?
load 'data'
data1=data(:,1:4:end); %get all data from data collection 1 into one table
data2=data(:,2:4:end); %get all data from data collection 2 into one table
data3=data(:,3:4:end); %get all data from data collection 3 into one table
data4=data(:,4:4:end); %get all data from data collection 4 into one table
%% Variable 1
% Comparison 1 (data collection 1 vs data collection 2)
p_acc_z_mean_1vs2=[data1(:,1),data2(:,1)];
p_acc_z_mean_1vs2 = table2array (p_acc_z_mean_1vs2);
[r_p_acc_z_mean_1vs2]=ICC(p_acc_z_mean_1vs2,'C-k',0.05,0.5);
% Comparison 2 (data collection 1 vs data collection 3)
p_acc_z_mean_1vs3=[data1(:,1),data3(:,1)];
p_acc_z_mean_1vs3 = table2array (p_acc_z_mean_1vs3);
[r_p_acc_z_mean_1vs3]=ICC(p_acc_z_mean_1vs3,'C-k',0.05,0.5);
% Comparison 3 (data collection 1 vs data collection 4)
p_acc_z_mean_1vs4=[data1(:,1),data4(:,1)];
p_acc_z_mean_1vs4 = table2array (p_acc_z_mean_1vs4);
[r_p_acc_z_mean_1vs4]=ICC(p_acc_z_mean_1vs4,'C-k',0.05,0.5);
%% Repeat the above for the remaining 71 variables
  4 Comments
Tomaszzz
Tomaszzz on 1 Mar 2022
@Johan Pelloux-Prayer Thanks Johan. It seems to calcuate the output for all variables ale all comparisons as below. Can you post this as an answer please. Can the storing of the results be improved to get rid of empty rows?

Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Johan
Johan on 1 Mar 2022
Edited: Johan on 1 Mar 2022
(modified from comment to get rid of empty rows)
Maybe this would work for you ?
%transform your table in an array
workdata = table2array(data);
k=1;
for i = 1:4:size(workdata,2)
for j = 1:3
%apply your function to your data comparing i column to i+j columns
[tosave] = ICC([workdata(:,i),workdata(:,i+j)],'C-k',0.05,0.5);
%storing the results in a structure
results(k).r_p_acc_z_mean(j) = tosave';
end
k=k+1;
end
  2 Comments
Johan
Johan on 1 Mar 2022
Yes my bad, I put the k=k+1 statement in the wrong for loop, I edited the answer above to fix it

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (2)

Jan
Jan on 1 Mar 2022
This is a first point to start from:
load 'data'
Calling load without catching the output creates variables dynamically. This can impede the JIT-acceleration massively can low down the code especially in loops. In addition it makes debugging much harder, because it is not visible in the code, if a specific name is a variable or a function.
Avoid hiding indices in the names of variables as in "p_acc_z_mean_1vs3". Use an array instead. Then you can call the variables in a loop using indices.
The JIT acceleration can suffer from changing the types of variables. Avoid to create a new table and convert it to an array using the same name:
p_acc_z_mean_1vs2 = [data1(:,1), data2(:,1)]; % Create 2 tables and join them
p_acc_z_mean_1vs2 = table2array (p_acc_z_mean_1vs2); % Expensive re-typing
A cheaper version:
p_acc_z_mean_1vs2 = data2{:,1:2}; % Numeric matrix in one step

Matt J
Matt J on 1 Mar 2022
Edited: Matt J on 1 Mar 2022
It would improve things modestly if you just convert all the data to an array from the get-go. It doesn't look like you're exploiting the features of table form in any way.
load 'data'
data=table2array(data);
data1=data(:,1:4:end); %get all data from data collection 1 into one table
data2=data(:,2:4:end); %get all data from data collection 2 into one table
data3=data(:,3:4:end); %get all data from data collection 3 into one table
data4=data(:,4:4:end); %get all data from data collection 4 into one table
However, I think the only significant gains that can happen is if you rewrite/vectorize ICC.m so that it processes many variables simultaneously, e.g.., to support syntax like this:
M=permute( cat(3,data1,data2) ,[1,3,2]);
out = ICC(M,'C-k',0.05,0.5);
  3 Comments
Tomaszzz
Tomaszzz on 1 Mar 2022
Thanks Matt, I find the below very useful as I have another function which requires the input data to be structured in this way and I had no clue how to do this
M=permute( cat(3,data1,data2) ,[1,3,2]);

Sign in to comment.

Tags

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!